
New Homes Undercut Existing Ones by $39,600, NAHB Index Shows
New homes cost $393,300 versus $432,900 for existing ones in Q3 2026, the NAHB/Wells Fargo index shows. San Jose families need 79% of income for a resale mortgage.
- Section
- Urbanism & Planning
- Author
- By Elena Vasquez
- Filed
- Length
- 3 min read
Key takeaways
- Median new-home price was $393,300 in Q3 2026, down 4.2% from $410,700 in Q2.
- Median existing-home price was $432,900, a $39,600 gap over new construction.
- A median-income family ($106,800) needs 33% of income for a new home, 36% for an existing one.
- San Jose families need 79% of income for a median existing-home mortgage, the highest of 175 metros.
- Eight of 175 metros are severely cost-burdened; low-income families there would owe 122%–157% of income.
A median-priced new home cost $393,300 in the third quarter of 2026 — $39,600 less than a median-priced existing home at $432,900, according to the NAHB/Wells Fargo Cost of Housing Index (CHI). That gap kept new construction the relative bargain in a market the index's publishers still call largely unaffordable.
The numbers moved in the right direction over the summer. The median new-home price fell 4.2% from $410,700 in the second quarter, while the existing-home median slipped just 0.5% from $434,900. In other words, builders cut prices roughly eight times faster than the resale market did.
What does a family actually pay?
The CHI translates prices into a share of income. A family earning the national median income of $106,800 needed 33% of its earnings to cover the mortgage on a median new home, down from 34% in the second quarter. A low-income family — defined as one earning half the median — would need 66% of its income for that same new home, down from 67%.
Existing homes run hotter on both counts. A typical family pays 36% of income for a median existing home; a low-income family needs 73%. For context, lenders and housing planners generally treat anything above 30% as a cost burden.
Which markets are severely cost-burdened?
The index covers 175 metropolitan areas. In eight of them, the typical family must spend more than half its income to buy a median-priced existing home — the index's threshold for "severely cost-burdened." Another 87 markets fall in the cost-burdened band of 31% to 50%, while 80 markets sit at or below 30%.
The five most severely cost-burdened markets:
- San Jose-Sunnyvale-Santa Clara, Calif. (79%)
- Urban Honolulu, Hawaii (73%)
- San Diego-Chula Vista-Carlsbad, Calif. (70%)
- San Francisco-Oakland-Fremont, Calif. (66%)
- Barnstable Town, Mass. (61%)
San Jose tops the list: a typical family there would hand over four of every five dollars earned to the mortgage. Low-income families in all five markets face an impossible math problem — the mortgage would consume between 122% and 157% of their income.
The five least cost-burdened markets, with Davenport-Moline-Rock Island making it six at a tied 20%:
- Decatur, Ill. (17%)
- Elmira, N.Y. (18%)
- Peoria, Ill. (19%)
- Wichita Falls, Texas (20%)
- Springfield, Ill. (20%)
- Davenport-Moline-Rock Island, Iowa-Ill. (20%)
Low-income families in these markets would need between 34% and 41% of income for the same payment — roughly what a median-income family spends in Honolulu or San Jose.
Why the new-home discount matters
The price gap is the mechanism behind the affordability split. Builders dropped prices fast enough in Q3 to pull the new-home payment share down a point, while the resale market barely moved. If existing-home prices keep holding while builders keep cutting, the cost advantage of new construction widens — and the resale market stays out of reach for lower-income buyers in most coastal metros. Full tables are available at nahb.org/chi.
Source: eyeonhousing.org
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering money, funding and market shifts around construction industry, architecture, interior design at Built Current.
384 articles

