Builder Sentiment Continues to Fall on Affordability Concerns
Builder Sentiment Continues to Fall on Affordability ConcernsRoger Starnes Sr / unsplash

Construction

Builder Confidence Falls to 25, Lowest Since April 2012

Builder confidence fell four points to 25 in November, the lowest since April 2012, as 46% of builders cut prices — the highest share of the post-Covid period.

Author
By Grace Kim
Filed
Length
3 min read

Key takeaways

  • Builder confidence fell four points to 25 in November, the lowest since April 2012.
  • 46% of builders cut prices in November — a post-Covid high — with average reductions at 6% for an eighth straight month.
  • 68% of builders offered sales incentives, the 20th consecutive month above 60%.
  • The buyer traffic index fell two points to 16, its lowest in 15 years excluding the 2020 pandemic start.
  • All regions declined; the West fell three points to 23 and the South three points to 27 on three-month moving averages.

Builder confidence in the market for newly built single-family homes fell four points to 25 in November — a 14-year low, according to the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB)/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index (HMI). It's the weakest reading since April 2012.

The November survey captures a market squeezed from both directions. On the supply side, builders face material costs pushed higher by tariffs, a persistent shortage of construction workers, and regulations the NAHB says undermine housing affordability. Stepped-up immigration enforcement is affecting labor availability in some markets, and higher fuel prices are prompting subcontractors to raise their rates.

Demand isn't holding up either. Mortgage rates above 7%, softer consumer confidence and an uncertain economic outlook are keeping buyers on the sidelines. The result: single-family home builders are pulling back on construction volumes.

How are builders responding?

With sales stalling, incentives and price cuts have become the industry's standard toolkit — and November set records for the post-Covid period.

  • 46% of builders reduced prices in November, the highest share since the pandemic began.
  • The average price reduction held at 6% for an eighth straight month.
  • 68% of builders offered sales incentives, also a post-Covid high.
  • November marked the 20th consecutive month in which at least 60% of builders used incentives.

What do the component indices show?

All three major HMI indices lost ground in November. The index measuring current sales conditions fell six points to 28. The index gauging future sales expectations dropped two points to 30. The index charting prospective buyer traffic slipped two points to 16 — its lowest level in 15 years, excluding the start of the pandemic in 2020.

A buyer-traffic score of 16 means builders are seeing remarkably thin foot traffic, a signal that weak sales today may not rebound quickly. Any HMI reading above 50 indicates more builders view conditions as good than poor; the overall index sits at half that threshold.

Regionally, the picture darkened across the board. Looking at three-month moving averages, the Northeast dropped four points to 34, the Midwest fell five points to 35, the South declined three points to 27, and the West posted a three-point decline to 23. The West and South — regions that carried much of the pandemic-era construction boom — now sit furthest below the neutral mark.

What does this change for housing affordability?

For buyers, the immediate effect is leverage: record shares of price cuts and incentives mean negotiability on new homes is the widest it's been since Covid hit. For the broader market, the pullback points the other way — fewer starts deepen the long-run supply shortage that helped push prices up in the first place.

The NAHB derives the HMI from a monthly survey it has conducted for more than 40 years, asking builders to rate current single-family sales, six-month sales expectations and prospective buyer traffic. The full HMI tables are available at nahb.org/hmi. The next reading will show whether a 14-year-low index can find a floor — or whether affordability pressure keeps dragging confidence into 2026.

Source: eyeonhousing.org

builder-confidence housing-market homebuilding nahb-hmi mortgage-rates

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Staff writer covering money, funding and market shifts around construction industry, architecture, interior design at Built Current.

348 articles

More projects

« Previous article