Friday roundup: Election day fallout for Blazers, Stars arena plans, Rays stadium
Friday roundup: Election day fallout for Blazers, Stars arena plans, Rays stadiumLuckyLife11 / pixabay

Urbanism & Planning

Election Day Rewrites the Math for Blazers, Stars and Rays Arenas

Plano voters killed $700M in Stars arena taxes, Florida's property tax cut undercuts the Rays plan, and Sen. Wyden now holds Senate Finance leverage over any Blazers move.

Author
By Priya Raman
Filed
Length
3 min read

Key takeaways

  • Plano voters rejected tax surcharges for $700 million toward a Dallas Stars arena on Tuesday.
  • Florida voters approved a statewide property tax cut, undercutting Tampa's Rays stadium financing plan.
  • Sen. Ron Wyden is poised to chair the Senate Finance Committee and has threatened to reexamine federal tax policy if the Blazers move.
  • The Las Vegas A's still lack funding for a $200 million parking garage and pedestrian plaza.
  • Tourism Economics projected $21.7 billion in Jaguars impact through 2052, including Super Bowls the owner says Jacksonville won't host.

Plano, Texas voters rejected tax surcharges that would have funded $700 million toward a new Dallas Stars arena on Tuesday. Plano city manager Mark Israelson said: "Without authorization for these venue taxes, the proposed financing approach would need to be reassessed before City Council considers any actions related to the arena." That's bureaucratese for back to the drawing board.

Election night hit at least three stadium deals at once. Here's what changed for each.

What does Plano's 'no' mean for the Stars?

The Dallas Stars plan is not dead. It's unfinanced. Plano's rejection of Proposition A (the tax surcharge package) leaves owner Tom Gaglardi's $700 million public ask without a revenue stream.

Some Dallas officials now see an opening. They hope Plano's reluctance to fund Gaglardi gives Dallas a chance to fund him instead, per FOX 4 News. One would hope a city with leverage would offer less money now that Gaglardi has fewer alternatives. History says otherwise — when Ted Leonsis's Virginia arena plan died, he grabbed the first half-billion-dollar check he could find in Washington, D.C.

Can Wyden block a Blazers move?

U.S. Sen. Ron Wyden of Oregon said he spoke with Miami Heat owner Micky Arison, chair of the NBA Board of Governors, about the Portland Trail Blazers arena talks and the possibility of the team relocating. Wyden said he "came away appreciative of his interest and encouraged by his counsel."

That's not a promise the NBA would block a move. But Tuesday's election results put Wyden in line to chair the Senate Finance Committee. He has previously threatened to reexamine federal tax policies for pro sports teams if the Blazers moved, so Blazers owner Tom Dundon now faces leverage running both directions.

Wyden may not drive a hard bargain, though. He has already let himself be photographed hanging out with former NBA stars alongside Dundon.

What does Florida's tax cut do to the Rays stadium plan?

Tampa's plan to help pay for a Tampa Bay Rays stadium leaned on property tax proceeds from a surrounding mixed-use district. Florida voters approved a sweeping statewide property tax cut on Tuesday, cutting into exactly that revenue base. Investigative reporter Noah Pransky flagged the collision immediately.

The stadium financing scheme now needs a new money source that the source material doesn't identify.

Quick hits from around the leagues

  • Las Vegas A's: Construction is underway, but financing for a $200 million parking garage topped by a pedestrian plaza remains unresolved. Bally's, which was supposed to build it, is now more cash-strapped than owner John Fisher. The team is planning a temporary interim plaza.
  • Chicago Bears: Commentary suggests Indiana was played to drive up Illinois's subsidy offer — and Indiana officials are still bidding anyway, with local coverage describing the race as a Bears stadium bid "in the red zone."
  • Jacksonville Jaguars: Reason's Jon Loesche examined Tourism Economics' 2023 report backing the $775 million stadium renovation. Of its projected $21.7 billion in economic impact between 2028 and 2052, about $700 million comes from "mega events visitor & operator spending," including a Super Bowl. Owner Shahid Khan said in 2016 that Jacksonville would "absolutely not" host another Super Bowl, citing too few hotel rooms, and repeated that to talkSport last year.

Economist J.C. Bradbury calls such consulting reports "propaganda" where "the goal is to concoct a big number, not an accurate number."

  • Milwaukee Brewers: Tom Verducci at Sports Illustrated notes Jacob Misiorowski's fastball works better in Tampa Bay, likely because the Rays play at sea level. The Brewers won the World Series anyway.

The pattern across all of it: voters keep narrowing the public-money pipeline while owners keep shopping for the next jurisdiction willing to open it.

Source: fieldofschemes.com

sports-arenas stadium-financing public-private-partnerships sports-infrastructure tax-policy

Share this article:

More from Priya Raman

Priya Raman

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in construction industry, architecture, interior design at Built Current.

306 articles

More projects

« Previous articleNext article »