CNN analysis uncovers construction flaws in public housing towers that collapsed during Venezuela quakes
CNN analysis uncovers construction flaws in public housing towers that collapsed during Venezuela quakesjarmoluk / pixabay

Construction

CNN analysis finds apparent rebar flaws in Venezuela housing collapses

CNN’s visual review found apparent rebar-code violations at five complexes linked to 15 public-housing tower collapses after Venezuela’s June 24 earthquakes.

Author
By Elena Vasquez
Filed
Length
5 min read

Key takeaways

  • Venezuela’s June 24, 2026 earthquakes had magnitudes of 7.2 and 7.5; 15 Caraballeda public-housing towers fell.
  • Every collapsed tower exceeded eight stories and contained at least 240 apartments.
  • CNN verified more than 40 photos and videos; only a small minority showed properly bent stirrups.
  • Five complexes showed apparent 90-degree bends against a 135-degree code requirement.
  • Satellite imagery showed 63% of Caraballeda’s public-housing high-rise towers collapsed.

By Elena Vasquez

Fifteen public-housing towers in Caraballeda collapsed in Venezuela’s 7.2- and 7.5-magnitude earthquakes on June 24, 2026. Each exceeded eight stories and contained at least 240 apartments, CNN reported. The government has released no comprehensive list of the dead, and CNN reported that thousands of public-housing residents likely perished.

A CNN review of more than 40 verified photos and videos found only a small minority of visible stirrups properly bent. Images from five government-built complexes showed some bent to 90 degrees, against Venezuela’s 135-degree code, and deep-seated rust in rebar at three complexes.

CNN said the evidence suggests construction flaws may have contributed to the mass tragedy, though it could not determine whether every fallen tower shared the defects.

Structural engineer Kit Miyamoto said: “This is how a concrete structure fails if it’s not done right.” He compared the defect to a wine barrel without properly assembled steel straps.

CNN reported that Miyamoto, who has led post-earthquake assessments worldwide, now works with roughly 100 engineers under Venezuela’s Ministry of Public Works to assess surviving buildings. He told CNN the stirrup problem was pervasive in the La Guaira rubble he assessed.

CNN reported that Ailin Quiroz climbed through her 13-story tower’s ruins for hours, looking for her sister and six other relatives. She found no trace and asked: “Why did their building collapse while other nearby high-rises survived?”

Venezuela’s government commission began analyzing nearly 100 affected buildings through material samples and measurements after the quakes, commission President Francisco Garcés told CNN.

Why were the towers built so quickly?

CNN reported that the towers were commissioned in 2011 by then-President Hugo Chávez. For nearly a decade, residents complained of persistent water intrusion, damaged pipes and sewage leaks, according to local media. The 15 towers formed part of dozens built across Venezuela, many intended for families displaced by a 2010 flooding and landslide disaster.

CNN reported that the Presidential Office of Special Plans and Projects (OPPPE), created two years earlier to build three million homes in nine years, oversaw the coastal complex near the San Sebastián fault line. The developments went up in barely a year.

Then OPPPE director and chief architect Francisco Sesto wrote in his personal blog that Chávez demanded 200,000 homes in 2012 alone. Former OPPPE principal Lucas Pou said emergency no-bid contracts were standard practice for speeding construction, but said he had not worked on the Caraballeda projects.

Sesto called the mission “a gigantic effort carried out with an intensity never before seen in Venezuela” and wrote that teams worked two to three shifts every day. He did not answer CNN’s repeated requests.

Sesto told The New York Times that he did not consider it “journalistically sound to focus on a handful of Great Mission buildings that collapsed, given that hundreds of private buildings also collapsed.” CNN estimated that tens of thousands of buildings were likely damaged or destroyed.

CNN reported that the OPPPE developments were among the largest residential buildings to fall in coastal La Guaira. Satellite imagery showed that 63% of Caraballeda’s high-rise towers built by a special public housing authority collapsed. Interim President Delcy Rodríguez had suspended OPPPE in February, a few months before the earthquakes.

How did the rebar depart from the code?

Venezuela’s 2006 building code required short rebar pieces, or stirrups, to bend 135 degrees in every high-rise in La Guaira. The bend makes earthquake forces less likely to break or unseat the ties reinforcing beams and columns. Images from construction beginning in 2011 and from after the 2026 earthquakes showed some at 90 degrees, likely violating the regulation.

Jeffrey Dowgala and Terrence Paret, structural engineers with earthquake-resilience expertise at Wiss, Janney, Elstner Associates, said a few improperly assembled stirrups can compromise a beam or column during strong shaking. Experts told CNN that the defect could separate catastrophic failure from a structure holding together, while cautioning that direct causation remains difficult to prove after massive tremors.

CNN’s review of a March 2012 OPPPE inspection photograph appears to show defective stirrups at the foundation of one tower in OPPPE 27. All four towers there collapsed 14 years later. Experts said ruin photographs showed that some defects were never corrected.

CNN’s images of at least two fallen complexes also showed closely spaced rebar strands that experts said were rarely bundled. The 2006 code required strands to be bundled or separated by at least one bar diameter, sometimes more.

What else weakened the concrete?

Footage after the quakes appeared to show deep-seated rust in rebar at at least three collapsed complexes. Miyamoto estimated that about half of the collapsed buildings in the area showed corrosion. CNN reported that Caraballeda’s tropical, beachfront climate and possible impurities in the concrete could also have eroded the metal bars.

Two construction workers told The New York Times that their team stretched materials by mixing other products into the concrete. The Times also found no visible shear walls in the towers and reported that uniformly oriented columns weakened the high-rises against seismic forces.

Quiroz recalled no similar incidents and saw no major water or sewage leaks. A neighbor who often visited friends in OPPPE 26 told CNN: “the floor would crack from any impact.”

In October 2025, another OPPPE 26 resident told La Verdad de Vargas that a living-room ceiling fragment injured his wife. “Luckily, she was able to cover her head and only suffered a shoulder injury,” he said.

What remains unresolved?

CNN reported that several OPPPE towers remain standing near Caraballeda. Just over half a mile east, OPPPE 25 contains nearly 700 apartments across seven towers; five survived the earthquakes and were evacuated. Displaced residents now camp in tents outside, resident María Sánchez told CNN.

A 2012 construction photograph of OPPPE 25 shows the same 90-degree stirrup bends. It remains unclear whether the five evacuated towers can return to use. The commission’s pending material tests and measurements will bear on that decision and on any broader response to defects across the OPPPE portfolio.

CNN received no response from Venezuela’s Communications Ministry, the government, or the office of La Guaira mayor José Manuel Suárez Maldonado. The commission’s pending material tests and measurements are the next basis for deciding whether surviving structures can return to use and how officials address defects across the wider OPPPE portfolio.

Source: localnews8.com

rebar structural-engineering earthquake-resilience building-codes public-housing

Share this article:

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering money, funding and market shifts around construction industry, architecture, interior design at Built Current.

354 articles

More projects

« Previous articleNext article »