Immigrant neighborhood in Brooklyn leans on faith and community while demanding accountability after deadly building col
Immigrant neighborhood in Brooklyn leans on faith and community while demanding accountability after deadly building colPhotomat / pixabay

Construction

Eight Dead in Brooklyn Collapse; 98 Open Violations on the Building

Eight people died when a 1930 Flatbush building with 98 open violations collapsed. The immigrant community grieves — and demands the city answer for it.

Author
By Amara Osei
Filed
Length
5 min read

Key takeaways

  • Eight people, including two children, died in the November 12 collapse of a three-story building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue.
  • The building had 98 open housing violations; owner Olufemi Falade served 12 days in jail in 2006 for hundreds of uncorrected violations.
  • Mayor Zohran Mamdani vowed full accountability; authorities are inspecting about 100 city locations linked to the site.
  • Victims included three Colombian citizens, two Ecuadorian men and a 26-year-old Guatemalan man; more than a dozen were injured.
  • The Department of Buildings has not determined the cause; facade cracks had been reported during permitting for adjacent construction.

Eight people — six adults and two children — died when a three-story mixed-use building collapsed on Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn on Veterans Day, and the city's own records show the structure carried 98 open housing violations. More than a dozen people were injured. The building dates from 1930.

The New York City Department of Buildings has not determined the cause. An investigation is underway, and authorities are inspecting roughly 100 locations across the city linked to the site.

On Thursday, grief took physical form outside Bethesda Church of God in Christ, directly across from the wreckage. Leonor Yupa dropped to her knees when a Spanish-language reporter said her 22-year-old son, Gabriel Siguencia, was among the dead.

"I want my son! I want my son!" the Ecuadorian mother cried in Spanish as relatives held her up and churchgoers assured her the reports were unconfirmed. They weren't rumors for long. Consul General of Ecuador Gicela Andrade Valens later confirmed Siguencia's death to his mother outside a nearby YMCA. Siguencia had arrived from Ecuador about a month earlier and had worked roughly two weeks as a carpenter at the construction site next to the collapsed building, according to uncles, cousins and family friends.

"He came to America looking for the same opportunities that people from all over the world come here for," family friend Javier Ortega said. "That's why he was working there."

Another woman, told Thursday morning that her husband's body had been pulled from the debris, collapsed in the sanctuary and wailed his name: "Tomás! Tomasito!" Family members formed a prayer circle around her.

Who were the victims?

The dead include three Colombian citizens, two Ecuadorian men — Siguencia and 26-year-old José Luis Caguana Cosquillo — and a 26-year-old Guatemalan man, officials from those countries announced. Colombia's consulate in New York said two Colombian children and one adult were killed.

"The Consulate of Colombia in New York reiterates its most sincere condolences to the victims' families and loved ones," the consulate said in a statement.

The Ecuadoran consulate said: "We express our deepest condolences to his family and loved ones, and we stand with them in profound solidarity in these moments of grief."

Mayor Zohran Mamdani, addressing reporters Thursday, framed the loss in the neighborhood's own terms.

"These were our friends and our neighbors, parents and children, young families building their lives in our city, and immigrants from Mexico, Colombia, Ecuador, Trinidad, and beyond," Mamdani said, vowing to hold anyone responsible "fully accountable."

A six-month pregnant woman was rescued from the rubble; her husband rejoiced at word she was safe. Others weren't so lucky. Teacher Katie Stevens, who lives a block away, sobbed as she watched first responders load body bags into a van Thursday morning. "I care for my neighbors so much," she told CNN. "I'm just so sad."

How did the neighborhood respond?

Pastor Alfred Justin Joseph turned his church into an open sanctuary. "They were standing in the street. I let them in," he said. "Thank God we have counselors in the church — people who do counseling for grief." A dozen people came in the first wave; some have since moved to a local YMCA or hotels. The Red Cross, NYC Human Resources Administration and World Central Kitchen supplied emergency shelter, supplies and updates on the missing.

Flatbush resident Joy Kerr heard a young widow crying hysterically and spent half an hour listening before acting.

"No, I can't take this. I can't sit back and just watch her and listen to her cry so hysterically," Kerr said. "In that moment, I knew she needed comfort." She gathered a prayer circle.

"This is devastating," Kerr said. "Nothing like this has ever happened in this neighborhood, and we just need to come together and stay together as a community."

Florence Saint-Jean, a psychologist offering mental health and trauma services at the Haitian Creole-speaking church, put the response plainly: "The people who live here are immigrants, and so when crisis happens, there's only one language — love."

James Williams, a bricklayer who has lived in the neighborhood for 35 years, watched the walls cave in Wednesday. One image stayed with him: a woman climbing an exposed staircase as everything around her crumbled. "I don't know if she got out alive or not," he said. "To see that and not know what happened to her…I might have to go see a psychiatrist."

Who owns the building, and what did the city know?

The question neighbors kept asking — how could this happen — has a paper trail.

The owner, Olufemi Falade, reportedly served 12 days in jail in 2006 for failing to repair hundreds of violations across multiple buildings. The collapsed building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue currently has 98 open violations, according to New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development records — from unsafe electrical wiring and missing smoke detectors to bedbug infestations and inadequate water supply for the sprinkler system. CNN has reached out to Falade for comment.

Investigators are examining both the condition of the building and activity at the adjacent construction site, whose permitting process included reports of cracks in the facade of the older building. Crews finished searching the rubble Thursday and determined no more survivors remained.

Building collapses are rare in the U.S., but housing experts and advocates point to systemic inequities — old buildings, lax code enforcement, rapid construction — that hit working-class immigrant communities hardest.

"We need better and faster tools to hold landlords accountable and to make sure that buildings are properly maintained and managed," said Sumathy Kumar, executive director of New York State Tenant Bloc and Housing Justice for All, noting the landlord's extensive history with the city.

Saint-Jean said the concern in Flatbush runs deeper than one collapse. "What we're most concerned about is, when things like this happen, that our voice (is) not being heard about development in the area," she said.

With 100 linked locations now under inspection and the mayor promising full accountability, the answer to the neighborhood's question will likely arrive in the Department of Buildings' findings — and, residents insist, in what the city does about them.

Source: localnews8.com

building-collapse housing-violations building-safety code-enforcement brooklyn

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in construction industry, architecture, interior design at Built Current.

354 articles

More projects

« Previous articleNext article »