
Waveny House Elevator Delayed Again as Parts Hold Up $2.5 Million Project
The $2.5 million Waveny House elevator, slated for April and then late summer, faces new delays. Tiger Mann: installers "needed some additional parts."
- Section
- Renovation & Retrofit
- Author
- By Marcus Bennett
- Filed
- Length
- 3 min read
Key takeaways
- The $2.5 million contract for the elevator and an ADA bathroom was approved in late 2022.
- Installation was originally due in April for wedding season, then pushed to late summer, and is now delayed again.
- Public Works Director Tiger Mann announced the delay at the Nov. 2 Board of Selectmen meeting; parts were due Nov. 3.
- First Selectman Dionna Carlson questioned why the town holds two or three separate elevator maintenance contracts.
- The manufacturer covers maintenance for the elevator's first year, after which the town can hire another firm.
By Marcus Bennett
The vintage "birdcage"-style elevator at Waveny House, once promised for April and then for the end of summer, is delayed again because installers "needed some additional parts," Public Works Director Tiger Mann said on Nov. 2.
The parts were due to arrive the following day. "They are arriving tomorrow [Nov. 3]," Mann told the Board of Selectmen during its meeting at Town Hall and via videoconference. "The guy is picking up and bringing them here. I am more frustrated than pretty much anybody else."
He offered no new completion date. "They didn't give us a timeframe on when it was going to be done, but they got some more parts that they have to put in," Mann said.
The comments came during his regular update to the selectmen on Public Works projects in town.
Why the elevator matters
The elevator is being installed alongside the grand staircase in the Waveny House main hall. Municipal officials had discussed the project for nearly a decade before the town approved a $2.5 million contract in late 2022. The contract covers both the elevator and an ADA-compliant bathroom.
The trigger was federal. An investigation found the second floor of Waveny House, home to the Recreation Department, was not accessible.
The timeline has already slipped twice. Installation was originally to finish in April, in time for Waveny's spring wedding season. Manufacturing and electrical problems with the elevator itself pushed the target to late summer. In June, officials said the work remained on track for completion by the end of summer. It was not.
What did the selectmen say about maintenance?
First Selectman Dionna Carlson used the delay to raise a broader procurement question. "I'm really getting nervous about the maintenance on that elevator, given the installation," she said.
"Why do we—just stepping back, because we have two different elevator maintenance companies, or three—why don't we have one elevator maintenance contract?" Carlson asked.
Bill Oestmann, buildings superintendent in the Department of Public Works, defended the fragmented approach on technical grounds. "Because when you have an Otis elevator and they have a good service, it's nice to have the manufacturer take care of their own equipment," he said. "KONE has proprietary equipment in there. No one can really touch this stuff without gouging you, it's happened before."
He did not soften the point. "I don't want to call it a 'racket' but this is how it is, unfortunately," Oestmann said. "Proprietary electronic stuff—as an example, the Police Department a year ago when the elevator failed there, I got annoyed at KONE and an outside company gave me a price twice as much, because KONE doubled the price for them to sell to me."
Can the town escape proprietary lock-in later?
Yes, according to Oestmann, and within a defined window. The manufacturer covers maintenance during the elevator's first year under the existing agreement. "And then after that we can bring it to some other people who are familiar with that type of operation," he said.
The hardware itself, he argued, is standard. "The elevator, all of it is operated in a similar fashion, all similar parts—it's just a question of the configuration of those parts and how they work," Oestmann said. "There's a hydraulic system, there's nothing that's really proprietary there. So generically, I could have another manufacturer or another company maintain it, should not be an issue."
He cited precedent from another town building. "The fire house is no different—that was a custom elevator there," Oestmann said.
For practitioners, the episode is a case study in proprietary-elevator procurement: a custom ornate fixture, a decade of deliberation, a $2.5 million accessibility contract, and a maintenance market where one manufacturer controls the parts. Once the first-year agreement expires, New Canaan's test will be whether a third party can service the machine without paying KONE's markup.
Source: newcanaanite.com
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around construction industry, architecture, interior design at Built Current.
374 articles

