The Francis Crick Institute at 10: Designing for Science No One Could Predict
The Francis Crick Institute at 10: Designing for Science No One Could PredictDarkoStojanovic / pixabay

Architecture

Ten Years In, the Francis Crick Institute Still Designs for the Unpredictable

Ten years after opening, HOK's Francis Crick Institute has helped launch 15 spinouts worth £1.5 billion — by engineering chance encounters rather than predicting science.

Author
By Amara Osei
Filed
Length
6 min read

Key takeaways

  • Queen Elizabeth II opened the Francis Crick Institute on Nov. 9, 2016; HOK was architect and lead designer with PLP Architecture collaborating.
  • The Crick's first decade produced 15 spinout companies that raised more than £1.5 billion and created over 600 jobs, per a Nature Medicine article.
  • R&D Magazine named the nearly 1-million-square-foot building its 2017 Laboratory of the Year; it holds a BREEAM Excellent rating.
  • HOK tested the lab module in full-scale mock-ups, including one built in a warehouse near Heathrow Airport in 2012.
  • Brian Connolly of HOK says 'flexibility matters more than prediction' as digital science outgrew the building's wet-lab assumptions.

Queen Elizabeth II opened the Francis Crick Institute on Nov. 9, 2016. A decade later, the building has helped launch 15 spinout companies that raised more than £1.5 billion and created over 600 jobs, according to an article published in Nature Medicine in April by three of the Crick's business and translation leaders.

Those numbers are the measurable output of a design experiment: nearly 1 million square feet of laboratory, write-up and collaboration space in central London, planned by HOK with PLP Architecture, and built on the premise that you cannot predict science. R&D Magazine named the Crick its 2017 Laboratory of the Year, and the building earned a BREEAM Excellent rating plus honors for planning and healthcare design.

HOK served as architect and lead designer, responsible for the overall design concept, laboratory planning, interior design and landscape architecture. PLP Architecture collaborated on the building's form and architectural expression.

How do you force scientists to talk to each other?

Sir Jim Smith, emeritus scientist at the Crick and the last director of the Medical Research Council's National Institute for Medical Research, borrows a term from competitive cycling: marginal gains. "In designing the place, we found as many tweaks as we could to make people collaborate," he says.

The tweaks were small and pointed:

  • Group leaders got small offices, so they "had to go into the collaboration spaces" for substantial meetings, Smith says.
  • Meeting rooms were grouped in one corner, forcing people to walk through the building to reach them. "Meetings always overrun, so they'd be standing outside the meeting rooms, chatting to people," he says.
  • Bridges, an open central stair and glass-fronted labs make people and research visible across floors.
  • Write-up desks sit directly outside the labs, connecting bench work with analysis and conversation.

"When you pass somebody on the stairs, you might be a bit out of breath, so you start talking to them," Smith says. "Little things, I think, but which added together lead to the effect we wanted, which was random interactions, bumping into each other, sharing ideas."

The building lets people see vertically as well as horizontally, Smith says: "In many buildings, you can see in X and Y, as it were, horizontally and to your left and right, but you can't see in Z. But in our building, you can see in Z as well." That visibility, he says, gives people "a sense of belonging to an overall community."

What did the scientists get to change?

Quite a lot, as it turns out. The lab module was tested first in a full-scale polyboard mock-up, then in a detailed full-scale mock-up built in 2012 in a warehouse near Heathrow Airport. Smith recalls busing researchers out to see it. The visit gave them "a chance to kick the furniture literally," he says, and "showed everybody in the institutes that their opinions were valued."

Smith and Sir Richard Treisman, then director of Cancer Research UK's London Research Institute and now a director of research at the Crick, set aside memories of their old buildings and focused on "what we thought a building for the next 40, 50 years should look like." The Crick merged the two predecessor institutes; its founding partners are the Medical Research Council, Cancer Research UK, Wellcome, University College London, Imperial College London and King's College London. A founding principle, "discovery without boundaries," meant no conventional departments or divisions.

Did the science outgrow the building?

Partly. Since design began in 2008, much research has moved from bench to desk, Smith says. "The use of the wet space is much less than we'd envisaged, and the use of the dry space is correspondingly greater." Researchers no longer pour and run gels at their benches; samples go to shared facilities for work like sequencing.

"Flexibility matters more than prediction," says Brian Connolly, HOK's regional leader of Science + Technology in London. "We've learned that it's impossible to accurately predict what science will look like 10 years in the future."

The labs use a kit-of-parts system, with casework that plugs into service spines and can be rearranged. The neighborhood plan lets one research group expand into adjacent space as another contracts. Even so, "digital science grew faster than anybody expected," Connolly says. Designing today, HOK would allocate more space and infrastructure to computational science from the outset.

Does physical proximity still matter?

Philippa Matthews, a clinical group leader at the Crick and professor of infectious diseases at University College London, thinks so. She studies hepatitis B. A neighboring group led by Pontus Skoglund studies ancient DNA and identified hepatitis B in ancient samples from archaeological excavations. The two groups, sitting intermingled in the building, now share doctoral students comparing ancient and modern samples of the virus.

Their partnership was "not strictly born of geography," Matthews says, but "the geography of our laboratory layouts and collaborative spaces ... is just a massive asset, because literally our groups are intertwined in the way they're sitting." The Crick's collaborative culture and its physical environment "go hand in hand," she says, "and you wouldn't be able to do one without the other."

Her work draws on lab scientists, clinicians, statisticians and genomics specialists, and combining those skills is hard to do remotely. "There's no substitute for having people together in the building," she says. The exchanges that matter are often unplanned: "It's not just 'We must have a meeting at 10 a.m. on Monday.' It's 'Oh, this bit of my code isn't working. Can you just have a look?'"

Connolly agrees: "As scientists become more digital, the physical workplace will become even more important as a place for collaboration, mentoring, creativity and innovation. The value of being together will increasingly come from the interactions that cannot happen remotely."

What came next?

The Crick "helped shift the conversation from designing laboratory buildings to designing research ecosystems," Connolly says. HOK carried that thinking into the University of Glasgow's Advanced Research Centre and Emory University's Health Sciences Research Building II. The Crick's expandable lab neighborhoods became "foundational to our approach," and the ARC "in many ways is a direct evolution of ideas tested at the Crick," he says.

The Nature Medicine authors list the institute's "distinctive architecture" among the strengths that made it a hub "linking innovators with funding, expertise and infrastructure."

The building sits beside St Pancras International railway station, a prominence Matthews reads as a statement: "It just says science is really important." In her field, hepatitis B "has always been neglected and not really talked about and stigmatized and underfunded," and welcoming patients and advocacy groups into the building lets them feel comfortable, inspired and represented.

Visitors "still just stand in the atrium and say, 'Wow,'" she says. The Crick hosts everyone from primary school groups to doctoral researchers, and has welcomed World Health Organization Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus and several heads of state since Matthews arrived in 2021.

"The building doesn't look like it's 10 years old," Smith says. "It looks like it was built yesterday." Matthews, who once believed she could work anywhere, has revised her position. "It's really taught me the importance of physical environment in a way that I just hadn't really thought about before," she says. For the next generation of research buildings, that may be the decade's lesson: design the interactions, not the science.

Source: hok.com

francis-crick-institute laboratory-design biomedical-research workplace-collaboration flexible-lab-planning

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in construction industry, architecture, interior design at Built Current.

398 articles

More projects

« Previous articleNext article »