Police Seek Clarifications from Town Council Ahead of Full Summertime Ban on Gas-Powered Leaf Blowers
Police Seek Clarifications from Town Council Ahead of Full Summertime Ban on Gas-Powered Leaf BlowersTama66 / pixabay

Green Building

Six Complaints, Zero Tickets: New Canaan Police Want Leaf Blower Ban Rewritten

New Canaan's summer ban on gas-powered leaf blowers produced six complaints and no tickets. Police Chief John DiFederico is asking the Town Council to fix the 'gray area' in the ordinance before next year.

Author
By Amara Osei
Filed
Length
4 min read

Key takeaways

  • New Canaan Police received six complaints during the first summer of the gas-powered leaf blower ban and issued no tickets.
  • The ordinance, passed 8-4 by the Town Council in May, bans gas-powered leaf blowers from Memorial Day weekend through Labor Day.
  • Police Chief John DiFederico flagged storm clean-up, the hard-surface exemption and the appeals process as ambiguous at a Nov. 5 committee meeting.
  • A July referendum failed to overturn the ordinance, which the town began debating four years ago.
  • A resident cited White Plains, N.Y., where complainants can electronically submit evidence of violations.

New Canaan Police logged just six complaints during the first summer of the town's gas-powered leaf blower ban — and issued zero tickets. Now Police Chief John DiFederico wants the ordinance rewritten before enforcement begins for real next year.

The ban, passed by the Town Council 8-4 in May after a July referendum failed to overturn it, prohibits gas-powered leaf blowers from Memorial Day weekend through Labor Day. Exemptions cover emergency and safety use, storm clean-up, the Department of Public Works, and residents using the machines on hard or man-made surfaces.

DiFederico told the Town Council Bylaws & Ordinances Committee at a Nov. 5 meeting that some of those accused this summer "were in compliance at the time we went there."

What's ambiguous in the ordinance?

The chief laid out three problems during the meeting at Town Hall and via videoconference:

  • Storm clean-up. "What would storm cleanup be?" DiFederico asked. "How long after a storm? If it rained on a Tuesday, can they use a gas-powered leaf blower on a Saturday? What is the definition of a storm? We have had perfectly clear days when we have had trees go down because it was a little windy. Does that constitute a storm?"
  • The hard-surface exemption. It's unclear whether it covers residents who also own a landscape business. "The way it's written it could be interpreted both ways," he said.
  • The appeal process. Police don't know whether Section 36A-7 of the Town Code, the general noise ordinance, governs challenges to leaf blower tickets. "We just want to make sure there's an avenue if people are cited for this that they have the proper legal channels to contest the citation," DiFederico said.

"Most were landscape companies that were not aware of the ordinance yet, so we educated them," he said of this summer's calls, adding that the ordinance "leaves some ambiguity or some gray area that we would request gets re-evaluated."

DiFederico said the clarification request anticipates next year, not the six complaints. During this year's five-week enforcement window, officers were instructed to educate, not cite.

How did the ban get here?

The town began debating restrictions four years ago. Supporters pushed for quieter summers and cited environmental and public health benefits. Skeptics warned of higher landscaping costs passed to taxpayers and enforcement headaches. Then came the council's 8-4 May vote and the failed July referendum.

Committee members asked whether the complaints triggered confrontations (no), disrupted police work (no — higher-priority calls win), and whether the chief had discussed appointing an outside enforcer with the first selectman (no). Mike Rodgers asked whether DiFederico had consulted Westport or Greenwich, which have stricter bans.

"We are not going to not enforce something that we receive a complaint on," DiFederico said. "We will use discretion when enforcing it and try to educate people. What we want to do with any law is we want voluntary compliance first before we cite people, but certainly we will reach out to other agencies."

What did residents say?

Ban supporters praised police during public comments. John Seel said locals "said how appreciative they were that they could enjoy their yards and their decks for the first time in years," calling enforcement "extra work that they may not have wanted to do, but it made a huge difference to the quality of life for all of us here in New Canaan."

John Fusek heard it "seemed to be a quieter summer," but cautioned: "I would not take too many conclusions from the five-week interim period last year, positively or negatively. I think this coming summer will be more indicative of where things will shake out."

Jill LaGattuta said her landscaper switched to electric blowers and kept using them after Labor Day. She also flagged White Plains, N.Y., where residents can electronically submit violation evidence and violators get ticketed — a model if New Canaan police can't shoulder enforcement alone.

With a full Memorial Day-to-Labor Day season ahead and ticketing now on the table, the committee's rewrite of the gray areas will determine whether next summer sounds different for reasons beyond the weather.

Source: newcanaanite.com

leaf-blower-ban new-canaan noise-ordinances municipal-enforcement environmental-policy

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in construction industry, architecture, interior design at Built Current.

354 articles

More projects

« Previous articleNext article »