Bouygues wins court fight over £15bn schools framework
Bouygues wins court fight over £15bn schools frameworkAnemone123 / pixabay

Construction

Bouygues defeats Government bid to kill £15bn schools framework claim

Bouygues UK's High Court challenge to its 0.13-point exclusion from the £15bn DfE schools framework will proceed after Mr Justice Coppel ruled the claim was not time-barred.

Author
By Marcus Bennett
Filed
Length
2 min read

Key takeaways

  • Bouygues missed the tenth and final place on the southern high-value lot by 0.13 points, scoring 74.67 to McLaren's 74.8.
  • Mr Justice Coppel ruled the claim was not time-barred because the 30-day Procurement Act 2023 deadline fell on a weekend.
  • One extra mark on any tender question, or one mark off McLaren's score, would have reversed the positions.
  • The £15bn framework has already been signed; damages may be a more likely remedy than a place on it.
  • The court has yet to rule on whether the DfE's tender evaluation was unlawful.

Bouygues UK has defeated a Government attempt to throw out its High Court challenge to the £15bn Department for Education construction framework, after missing the final place on the southern high-value lot by 0.13 points.

The contractor finished 11th with a score of 74.67, narrowly behind McLaren Construction on 74.8, which took the tenth and final place. Bouygues claims the DfE unlawfully evaluated its bid, making scoring errors and treating it unfairly compared with McLaren.

The Government tried to dismiss the challenge on timing grounds. It argued Bouygues had started court proceedings two days too late.

What did the judge decide?

The dispute centred on the 30-day deadline for launching a procurement challenge under the Procurement Act 2023. The DfE argued the deadline expired on Saturday 3 January; Bouygues lodged its claim electronically on Monday 5 January.

Mr Justice Coppel rejected the argument. Because the deadline fell on a weekend, it extended to the next working day.

He said: "The Claimant's claims are not time-barred."

The judge also ruled that even if Bouygues had missed the deadline, he would have granted an extension because of the unusual legal arguments and disruption caused by the Christmas shutdown.

What is the underlying dispute about?

The case turns on several tender questions, including one covering nature-based solutions, where Bouygues scored just two marks out of ten against an internal expectation of eight.

The margin is razor thin. The court heard that increasing Bouygues' score by a single mark on any question, or reducing McLaren's score by one mark, would have reversed their positions, assuming other scores stayed unchanged.

Bouygues has also challenged the moderation of tender scores and alleged shortcomings in the DfE's record-keeping.

What happens next?

The framework has already been signed, after Bouygues failed to trigger an automatic suspension before the extended standstill period expired. That fact shapes the remedies on offer.

The judge indicated that even if Bouygues ultimately succeeds, damages may be a more likely remedy than securing a place on the framework. The court has yet to decide whether the DfE's tender evaluation was unlawful.

For contractors bidding into public frameworks, the ruling confirms a practical rule under the Procurement Act 2023: a 30-day deadline that lands on a weekend rolls forward, and Christmas-period disruption can justify an extension. Losing bidders chasing single-mark margins now have both grounds and time.

Source: Construction Enquirer

bouygues-uk department-for-education school-construction public-procurement procurement-act

Share this article:

More from Marcus Bennett

Marcus Bennett

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around construction industry, architecture, interior design at Built Current.

388 articles

More projects

« Previous article