72 flats, combustible cladding, one disputed word: Allianz's fight over "imminent" fails at appeal
72 flats, combustible cladding, one disputed word: Allianz's fight over "imminent" fails at appealValterM / pixabay

Construction

Appeal sends 72-flat Portsmouth fire-risk claim to trial

The Court of Appeal sent Vivid Housing's claim over combustible cladding and missing cavity barriers at a 72-flat Portsmouth block to trial, ruling that “imminent” is a factual question.

Author
By Grace Kim
Filed
Length
4 min read

Key takeaways

  • The Court of Appeal dismissed Allianz's appeal on November 3, 2026.
  • Vivid's claim concerns 72 flats at Collins Place in Portsmouth.
  • The policy cover ran from May 22, 2008, to May 21, 2020.
  • Vivid notified the claim on or about May 19, 2020.
  • CBRE's assessment identified four defects in the facade and cavities.

By Grace Kim

The Court of Appeal dismissed Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty SE’s appeal on November 3, 2026, sending Vivid Housing Limited’s claim over fire-safety defects at a 72-flat Portsmouth block to a full trial.

Vivid Housing Limited owns the residential block at Collins Place in Portsmouth. At stake are repair costs for fire-safety defects across all 72 flats; the judgment states no monetary figure. No fire had broken out.

The case turns on whether those latent defects meet the policy’s word “imminent.” Allianz argued that passive cladding and cavity-barrier defects cannot trigger cover unless ignition itself is imminent—a fire about to break out.

The policy and four defects

Building LifePlans Ltd issued Vivid’s Housing Warranty Insurance Policy on Allianz’s behalf under a binding authority arrangement. Clause 3(a)(iii) covers repair costs where a defect causes “the threat of imminent destruction or physical damage to the Premises which requires immediate remedial measures.”

The cover ran from May 22, 2008, to May 21, 2020. On or about May 19, 2020, days before expiry, Vivid notified a claim under the policy.

CBRE’s facade fire risk assessment identified four defects:

  • Combustible Rockpanel cladding installed alongside combustible foam insulation
  • Missing vertical cavity barriers
  • Missing or defective horizontal cavity barriers
  • Construction debris left inside building cavities

CBRE rated the absence of compartmentation—the barriers designed to stop fire spreading unseen through wall cavities—as critical, its highest-priority category. The assessment found that the defects created a route for fire to spread through the facade cavity.

When Vivid filed its claim, it answered “N/A” to the question about whether urgent repairs were needed. It had nevertheless put a waking watch in place, a measure described on the form as “preventative and associated measures.”

Why the case must proceed to trial

Allianz sought to end the case through summary judgment, which would have disposed of the claim without a full trial. Its position was direct: no fire, no imminence. It argued that the policy responds only when something makes ignition itself imminent, rather than when passive defects create a dangerous risk.

For its summary-judgment application, Allianz accepted that the alleged defects counted as “Defects” under the policy. It also chose not to rely on a fire exclusion clause that, on its face, appeared to exclude this type of claim. Those concessions applied only to the application; Allianz reserved both points for trial.

The High Court’s Technology and Construction Court refused Allianz’s summary-judgment application on December 16, 2025. Applying an earlier case-law test, it asked whether a reasonable observer would regard the damage as “sufficiently likely to happen sufficiently soon.” The court found Vivid’s claim had a real prospect of success.

The court reasoned that fire risk is constant by nature and arises from a wide variety of causes. Requiring proof that a fire was about to break out, it said, would leave the policy with almost no practical application to fire-related defects. That, the court concluded, would not be a commercial reading of the policy.

The lower court also rejected Allianz’s reading of the waking watch. It said the measure pointed toward concern about “catastrophic damage both to persons and property” if fire broke out, rather than proving the absence of urgency.

The Court of Appeal found that the lower court had applied the correct legal test and reached a conclusion it was entitled to reach. Whether Collins Place’s fire risk was “sufficiently serious” and would “eventuate sufficiently soon” was a question of fact and degree, the appellate court said, and belonged at trial.

The appellate court acknowledged that Allianz’s interpretation of “imminent” was not unreasonable in the abstract. Still, it endorsed the lower court’s observation that Allianz’s approach would leave cover available only where something made ignition itself imminent. The court noted an obvious relationship between the severity of a risk and the urgency of remedial repairs, calling these “paradigm matters for resolution at a trial.”

Vivid’s current fire-risk evidence consists of the CBRE report and a schedule of fires across its property portfolio. One listed fire, unrelated to Collins Place, began in a kitchen fridge freezer. Vivid has indicated that it will seek to expand that evidence at trial.

What does this change for latent-defect claims?

The ruling narrows the scope for insurers to dispose of passive-defect claims before trial. For claims teams and underwriters working in latent defects and construction lines, it signals that courts will treat the meaning of “imminent” in fire-safety contexts as an inherently factual question.

The full trial must now determine whether the Collins Place defects satisfy clause 3(a)(iii). Vivid has indicated that it will seek additional evidence at trial, while Allianz retains its arguments on the definition of “Defects” and the fire exclusion. The Court of Appeal has deliberately left the policy’s response unresolved.

Source: insurancebusinessmag.com

fire-safety cladding cavity-barriers latent-defects construction-insurance

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Staff writer covering money, funding and market shifts around construction industry, architecture, interior design at Built Current.

324 articles

More projects

« Previous articleNext article »