Can a walkable downtown thrive in the heart of suburban sprawl? This city is putting that to the test
Can a walkable downtown thrive in the heart of suburban sprawl? This city is putting that to the testMasashiWakui / pixabay

Urbanism & Planning

A $52 Million Bet on Walkability Meets a Hostile New Council in Utah

Utah City's developer got $52.3 million from a public district in May. Vineyard's new council is now auditing who pays for the 700-acre walkable downtown.

Author
By Elena Vasquez
Filed
Length
5 min read

Key takeaways

  • A public infrastructure district paid $52.3 million to developer Flagborough LLC in May for Utah City, a 700-acre walkable project in Vineyard, Utah.
  • Vineyard paid Utah City developers $4.5 million in 2026; council members are reviewing what it covered.
  • Utah City studios rent for $1,325–$1,410 monthly versus a $1,199 average studio rent in Provo.
  • The project rises on the former Geneva Steel site near a FrontRunner station opened in 2022, with buildout expected in 15–20 years.
  • A Huntsman Cancer Institute hospital and research facility is set to open in Utah City in 2028.

A public infrastructure district paid $52.3 million to Flagborough LLC in May for Utah City, a 700-acre walkable community rising in Vineyard, Utah — and the city's new elected leaders want to know exactly where the public's money is going.

Utah City sits on the former site of Geneva Steel, an industrial complex built during World War II that went defunct in the 2000s and once covered nearly 2,000 acres. Flagborough LLC, a venture spearheaded by The Flagship Companies, one of Utah's largest housing developers, is building a dense, transit-oriented downtown from scratch next to a FrontRunner commuter rail stop that the Utah Transit Authority opened in 2022.

The first two apartment complexes, 120 and 220 Bend, were finished in February. Bella's Market, a grocery store with floor-to-ceiling glass, opened late last year across from the station, alongside Fini Pizza, a slice shop recruited from New York City. The developers expect to finish building Utah City in 15 to 20 years.

"The biggest benefit of this project, the greatest opportunity, is that the project's so big," said Nate Hutchinson, a partner in both Flagborough and The Flagship Companies.

Why is the new city council pushing back?

Vineyard's new mayor, Zack Stratton, and several new council members took office in January on a mandate to roll back policies they argue were too deferential to developers. The city paid Utah City developers $4.5 million in 2026 alone, and council members say they're reviewing what those payments covered.

"Maybe it can work, maybe it can't," said Council member Jacob Wood, who is 25. "It's a gamble, but they shouldn't be gambling with city money."

Council member David Lauret puts it more bluntly: "The problem we have is many of the citizens feel they're trying to use our money … toward building their business. It's all rental facilities. We're basically helping to hand them a business they'll make money with in perpetuity."

The financing mechanism is a Housing and Transit Reinvestment Zone, a state designation Vineyard won in 2022. As land values rise, local governments capture the new property tax income and pay developers for up to 25 years — covering parking garages, utilities, and the extra cost of building above four stories. The previous council also approved 10 public infrastructure districts in 2023, which issue bonds for roads, water pipelines and, in these zones, private improvements.

An investigation by the Utah State Auditor last year found Vineyard's Redevelopment Agency hadn't properly reported big payments to developers citywide, and a city-commissioned audit found poor oversight of RDA money. City officials said they still can't say how much taxpayer money the RDA has paid developers, including those at Utah City. The council has since hired a resident panel to probe past contracts. "Have we uncovered anything earth shaking? No," Lauret said.

Is it actually affordable?

Studio units at Utah City rent for $1,325 to $1,410 a month on a 17-month lease — parking, pet rent and most utilities not included. In Provo, 10 miles south, the average studio runs $1,199 and a two-bedroom averages $1,521, according to Rent.com. Utah City's two-bedroom units start at about $2,500.

Vineyard's original zone application promised "2,000+" attainable units costing 30% or less of household income. Council member Jacob Holdaway, a descendant of the pioneer family that named Vineyard after its table grapes, called it "a complete bait and switch." He wants more homes for sale, not rentals.

Hutchinson disputes that. "That was always the plan," he said of building parks, shops and eateries before for-sale housing. "To say it's a bait and switch … is factually not even close to being true." He defines affordability by HUD's standard — households earning up to 80% of area median income, or $66,750 for a single person and $95,350 for a family of four in Utah County. Under the 30%-of-income rule, that's a rent ceiling of roughly $1,670 to $2,380 a month.

Do Utahns even want density?

Stratton doesn't think so. "The plans are ambitious," the mayor said. "This is the reality: No one up and down the Wasatch Front wants density."

The numbers lean his way. In 2023, 78% of Americans and about 79% of Utahns drove to work, per U.S. Census Bureau estimates. In Utah County, nearly 66% of workers drive alone, 10% carpool and less than 2% take transit. Neighboring Orem dropped multifamily rentals last year in favor of single-family homes.

"Planners go in with the best intentions," said Sarah Moser, a professor of urban and cultural geography at McGill University. "Everyone wants mixed-use, dense, walkable, bikeable cities, but the population is not there."

Urban designer Jeff Speck, whom Flagship tapped for the project and who wrote 2012's "Walkable City," frames it differently: "The question isn't getting Americans to give up their cars. It's creating an environment in which they just want to use them less."

What happens next?

Backers have shifted. Woodbury Corporation, once Flagborough's joint-venture partner, quietly exited in early 2026 without explanation. Flagborough appears to have gained support from Sandlot Partners, an Orem-based private equity firm founded in 2020. "We still locally own and control a majority of the project," Hutchinson said, "and we care about it."

Vineyard abandoned a planned $35 million city hall in Utah City after Stratton led a signature campaign against it, though developers had offered to donate the land. Former council member and city manager Ezra Nair, a project supporter, resigned Aug. 30 for a job at Provo City. "Building takes time, but tearing down goes really fast," he said in June.

The developers point to anchors even skeptics praise: a Huntsman Cancer Institute hospital and research facility opening in 2028, plus planned light industrial, biomedical and future Utah Valley University facilities east of the rail line. "That's exciting for the state," Stratton said, "exciting for our city." For a 15-to-20-year buildout, that shared ground may matter more than the fights over its financing.

Source: localnews8.com

walkability transit-oriented-development affordable-housing urban-density public-private-financing

Share this article:

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering money, funding and market shifts around construction industry, architecture, interior design at Built Current.

354 articles

More projects

« Previous articleNext article »