
Shanghai Grand Opera House charges 50 RMB to climb its stair
Snøhetta's Shanghai Grand Opera House charges 50 RMB for its public stair. Aaron Betsky argues the backlash reveals a global pattern: walkable architecture blocked by fees and makeshift fences.
- Section
- Architecture
- Author
- By Marcus Bennett
- Filed
- Length
- 4 min read
Key takeaways
- The Shanghai Grand Opera House by Snøhetta charges 50 RMB (about $8) to climb its cantilevered public staircase.
- Aaron Betsky's Dezeen opinion links the fee to global restrictions on buildings designed for three-dimensional exploration.
- A decade ago, visitors could freely climb Ma Yansong's Harbin Opera House (2015) and the Kowloon High Speed Train Station.
- MVRDV's Rotterdam Depot and Hamburg's Elbphilharmonie remain free to climb but route visitors past commercial temptations.
- Betsky cites Ma's Lucas Museum in Los Angeles with park by Mia Lehrer as a model for designing access and safety together.
By Marcus Bennett
Snøhetta's Shanghai Grand Opera House charges visitors 50 RMB — roughly eight dollars — to ascend its cantilevered public staircase, and the backlash says as much about architecture's promises as about ticketing.
The controversy, addressed by critic Aaron Betsky in an opinion piece for Dezeen, exposes a widening gap between buildings designed as explorable landscapes and the barriers that increasingly regulate them. "Sooner or later, you will hit a barrier, usually makeshift and consisting of moveable fences and lots of yellow and black tape," Betsky writes.
Why does the fee matter beyond Shanghai?
China has led the world in buildings meant to be walked over. Ma Yansong's Harbin Opera House of 2015 offered a path above the auditorium; his Quzhou Sports Center is literally five scalable hills; the new Shenzhen Bay Cultural Center continues the approach. Andrew Bromberg of Aedas designed Hong Kong's Kowloon High Speed Train Station as a continuous curve rising over the waiting hall toward views of Hong Kong Island.
Snøhetta's completed Shanghai Grand Opera House extends the lineage with its stair overlooking the river and the city.
The fee, Betsky argues, reflects owners' economics. "Many building owners who have paid a little extra to get that architectural rizz have realized, once they see their building overwhelmed by selfie takers, that they can monetize their outlooks and prospects," he writes.
The response online has been sharper than reactions to earlier closures of Ma's climbable hills. Betsky notes the "digisphere is not happy" — people apparently feel that photographing themselves against an urban view should be a right, even though the institution, in this case funded largely by the state, invested in making the experience possible.
The pattern is global. "All over the world, buildings that were designed to be explored in three dimensions are often subject to restrictions," Betsky writes. "The fluidity of which architects dream drowns in a sea of concerns about safety and security."
How do Europe's restrictions compare?
European barriers are subtler but present. Visitors can reach the top of MVRDV's Depot Boijmans Van Beuningen in Rotterdam or Herzog & de Meuron's Elbphilharmonie in Hamburg for free, but must navigate routes that resemble the maze between airport security and the gates — and are tempted to buy a drink along the way.
Betsky accepts this. "Space and views are among the most valuable luxuries on offer, so, until the revolution comes, I do not see the big deal."
What is the real design failure?
The bigger problem, in his view, is the barriers themselves. Even visitors who pay in Shanghai find fences blocking not just access but the views and the architecture, because architects never designed them into the building.
Theo Deutinger's Handbook of Tyranny catalogs and diagrams such control devices. Betsky writes: "You can ignore the Eyes in the Sky hidden in the ceiling, but not the fences."
Ironically, post-construction barriers stand out more in China because there were until recently so few. A decade ago visitors could clamber over the Harbin Opera House and the Kowloon station. Local authorities now face consequences from government over mishaps in buildings they oversee — a shift architects in China tell Betsky is increasingly common.
Some outcomes are positive. Ramps and accessibility provisions are opening vertical landscapes to people with mobility issues, toddlers and older visitors. Architects who design tiered complexity risk excluding users, as Steven Holl learned in the lawsuit over his Hunters Point Library in Brooklyn.
Can architects design their way out?
Betsky's prescription is direct: design accessibility and risk-avoidance into vertical landscapes from the start. He cites Ma's Lucas Museum in Los Angeles, with its surrounding park by Mia Lehrer, as proof it can be done.
The deeper issue is the unfulfilled promise of fluid space itself. Zaha Hadid, in her folds and curves, "dreamed of a truly open architecture in which urban life would move without barriers" — a promise parametricism and Wolf Prix's decades-long call for an "open architecture of the open eye, the open mind, the open heart" repeated. Structure, headroom in blobs, and above all cost stand in the way.
"All conditioned space is conditional," Rem Koolhaas once said. Outside, Betsky concludes, the same now holds. Walkable building landscapes are promissory notes for an open society rather than built utopias — and economic and regulatory reality will bring climbers back down to earth.
Source: dezeen.com
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around construction industry, architecture, interior design at Built Current.
388 articles

