
FRC faults contractors and builders over unclear project risks
The FRC reviewed nine contractors and six house builders, finding weak disclosure of delays, disputed payments, losses and future liabilities despite praise for Balfour Beatty and Morgan Sindall.
- Section
- Construction
- Author
- By Grace Kim
- Filed
- Length
- 3 min read
Key takeaways
- The FRC reviewed 15 listed and private companies: nine contractors and six house builders.
- Only five of nine contractors referred to liquidated damages.
- Only two of five contractors with significant revenue and cost forecasts quantified how changes could affect their financial position.
- Three of six house builders omitted provisions for warranties, remedial works or completed-development costs.
- Persimmon warned that a 20% change in costs for uncontracted remediation schemes could move its provision by £17.2m.
Only five of nine contractors reviewed by the Financial Reporting Council (FRC) referred to liquidated damages, the penalties commonly charged for late completion. The FRC said such penalties are common in construction contracts. The regulator treated the narrow disclosure as part of a broader failure to explain uncertain contract income, disputed payments, delay penalties and potential losses.
The FRC's review covered 15 listed and private companies: nine contractors and six house builders. It focused on financial reporting disclosures, not on whether reported profits were accurate. The regulator did not examine liquidity, going concern or the wider financial health of the businesses.
The FRC praised Balfour Beatty and Morgan Sindall for their disclosure of contract income, variations and financial risks. It said both explained clearly how they account for those items. Balfour Beatty disclosed potential outcomes on a handful of long-term contracts, ranging from an £82m gain to a £44m loss.
The FRC gave Morgan Sindall particular praise for explaining how contract variations, delay penalties and disputed payments affect revenue calculations. That treatment gave readers a clearer account of risks that other contractors left obscure. The FRC nevertheless found that reporting of uncertain contract income across the sector generally fell short of expectations.
The FRC raised concerns about how firms reported projects running over budget or suffering delays. It found that only two of five contractors provided figures showing how changes could affect their financial position, although five classified revenue and cost forecasts as significant estimates. The FRC also found that some contractors bundled provisions for loss-making contracts, defects and warranty claims, making future financial hits harder to trace.
The FRC said: “Most companies did not describe sufficiently the uncertainties affecting the amount and timing of expected outflows or the key assumptions made in measuring the provisions.” Its criticism covered both the amounts recorded and the assumptions behind them.
House builders faced their own disclosure gaps. The FRC found that three of the six did not disclose provisions for warranties, remedial works or outstanding costs on completed developments, which the watchdog described as unusual. The regulator also said one company that had signed the Building Safety Repairs Pledge failed to recognise a provision or explain why it had not done so.
The FRC found that none of the six house builders quantified the value of land options carried in their inventories. It said this left investors with less information about money tied up in future development sites. House builders generally explained the assumptions behind revenue and cost forecasts better than contractors, the regulator found.
The FRC found clearer reporting in building safety liabilities than in many other areas. Firms generally provided clearer explanations of remediation liabilities. Seven companies carried building safety provisions, and six identified them as significant estimates.
Persimmon received specific praise for its reporting. The FRC highlighted a warning that a 20% change in estimated costs on uncontracted remediation schemes could move its provision by £17.2m. The watchdog treated the disclosure as an example of linking a cost assumption to a quantified financial effect.
What does this change for contractors and house builders?
The immediate change is clearer disclosure in the next set of accounts, rather than a finding that reported profits were wrong. The FRC called on the industry to improve its reporting of contract risks, disputed payments, potential losses and future liabilities. Balfour Beatty and Morgan Sindall provide examples of practices the watchdog wants others to match; the review identifies what weaker disclosures failed to show.
The next accounts will provide the test. Companies will need to show readers which assumptions drive revenue and cost forecasts, which provisions could absorb future losses, and how changes could affect their financial position.
Source: Construction Enquirer
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Staff writer covering money, funding and market shifts around construction industry, architecture, interior design at Built Current.
379 articles


