Earwitnesses, Split Maps and 1:1 Ghosts: Drawing Buildings That No Longer Exist
Five detainees reconstructed Saydnaya Prison from sound and memory. In Cyprus and Barcelona, architects map cities and buildings that exist only in testimony and archives.
- Section
- Architecture
- Author
- By Amara Osei
- Filed
- Length
- 3 min read
Key takeaways
- In 2016, Forensic Architecture and Amnesty International reconstructed Saydnaya Prison from the testimony of five former detainees.
- Lawrence Abu Hamdan documented a 19-decibel reduction in remembered whispering levels at Saydnaya after 2011.
- Saydnaya became physically accessible in December 2024 after the fall of the Assad government.
- Hands-on Famagusta presented its counter-mapping tools at the 2016 Venice Architecture Biennale.
- Memoria Cronotópica traced a Barcelona site at 1:1, including a medieval necropolis with sixteen burials from the 7th to 9th centuries.
Five former detainees, interviewed in Istanbul in 2016, reconstructed the interior of Saydnaya Prison from memory — most of them had never seen the cells they were describing. That is the starting premise of a strand of architectural research that treats testimony, not tape measures, as primary evidence.
Forensic Architecture worked with Amnesty International on the Saydnaya model, a military prison north of Damascus whose interior investigators could not enter. Starting from satellite imagery and earlier written testimony, researchers built a digital model that survivors walked through at eye level, correcting proportions and placing objects. Movement jogged memory. Details surfaced that witnesses had never mentioned.
Some dimensions came from the body. One survivor recalled the size of a hatch in his cell door because guards had forced his head through it. Another estimated a cell's dimensions by counting floor tiles.
What can sound tell an investigator?
Detainees were blindfolded, kept in darkness, and forbidden to speak. They learned the building through footsteps, doors, and noise traveling through water pipes and ventilation ducts. Audio investigator Lawrence Abu Hamdan gathered what the team called "ear-witness testimony," using simulated echoes and reverberations to help survivors recall spaces and estimate the dimensions of cells, corridors, and stairwells.
In his related work, Saydnaya (the missing 19dB), Abu Hamdan documented how enforced silence intensified after 2011 — including a 19-decibel reduction in the whispering levels survivors remembered. The accounts did not always agree. The team cross-referenced spatial and acoustic testimony, corrected discrepancies where possible, and documented those that remained.
The model's status changed in December 2024, when the fall of the Assad government opened Saydnaya to journalists, families, and investigators. The reconstruction can now be checked against the building itself. Yet the testimonies preserve something a survey cannot: how prisoners experienced those spaces through darkness, sound, and enforced silence.
How do you map a city two communities remember differently?
In Famagusta, Cyprus, the 1974 conflict displaced much of the Greek Cypriot population and left the coastal district of Varosha under Turkish military control. Former residents and those who stayed or arrived later knew the same city through what the Hands-on Famagusta team called split mental maps.
Led by architect and urbanist Socrates Stratis, the project built counter-mapping tools: large isometric drawings, an interactive digital platform, and a transportable physical model. The drawings documented enclaves, restricted areas, and boundaries. The model did the opposite — representing built areas, open landscapes, and neighborhoods as one continuous territory, so participants could examine relationships across political lines.
Stratis and Emre Akbil frame the approach through dissensus, treating disagreement as part of collective urban discussion. The tools were presented through Contested Fronts, the Cyprus Pavilion at the 2016 Venice Architecture Biennale.
Can a demolished building return at full scale?
Barcelona offers a third condition. For the 2022 Model Barcelona Architectures Festival, FLEXOARQUITECTURA created Memoria Cronotópica, transferring historical drawings of the former municipal courts site onto the ground at 1:1. Color-coded by period, the outlines traced:
- a medieval necropolis with sixteen burials from the 7th to 9th centuries
- the Fusina Gardens
- the Palau de Belles Arts, built for the 1888 Universal Exposition
Two temporary towers marked the original positions of the Palau's organs. During the festival, musician Juan de la Rubia performed an organ piece, briefly returning a sound associated with the demolished building to the site.
The installation also posed a question about reuse: whether the demolished courthouse could have been adapted, its materials salvaged, or temporary uses introduced alongside the plants and animals that had colonized the vacant plot.
Each project shows the same thing. Drawings preserve dimensions; they don't preserve experience. What enters the drawing — and what stays outside it — depends on whose knowledge builds it.
Original: forensic-architecture.org
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in construction industry, architecture, interior design at Built Current.
380 articles


